The 2026 college football season is here, and for card collectors that means a new chase is underway. Every fall brings fresh breakout candidates, rising draft stock, and a handful of players whose cardboard market can move quickly with every big Saturday performance.
After a 2025 season that saw Fernando Mendoza win the Heisman Trophy and lead Indiana to its first national championship, collectors are once again trying to identify the next players who can turn elite talent into major hobby momentum. The most intriguing names are not just the ones putting up numbers. They are the ones combining production, visibility, team context, and card appeal.
Here is OTIA Sports' Top 3 list of college football players card collectors should be watching most closely in 2026.
Top 3 college football players to watch for collectors
1. Jeremiah Smith, WR, Ohio State
If collectors are looking for the most electric non-quarterback in college football, Jeremiah Smith belongs at the top of the list. The Ohio State wide receiver enters his junior season after a standout 2025 campaign in which he posted 87 receptions, 1,243 receiving yards, and 12 touchdowns. His yardage total led the Big Ten, and his weekly ability to create explosive plays kept him firmly in the national spotlight.
For more collector background, read 5 NFL Players Who Could Shape the 2026 Season and Move the Football Card Market.
Smith's hobby case is easy to understand. He already has a strong profile, he plays for one of the sport's highest-visibility programs, and he is widely viewed as one of the most dangerous players in the country. That kind of combination tends to matter in the card market, especially when collectors are trying to get ahead of Heisman chatter and future NFL Draft buzz.
His 2026 outlook is also helped by continuity under center. Julian Sayin returns after leading all of college football in completion percentage at 77 percent in 2025, giving Ohio State one of the most dangerous passing tandems in the nation. For a star receiver, a stable quarterback situation can be one of the biggest factors in maintaining production and building even more momentum.
From a collector perspective, Smith already has an early card that many hobby participants recognize: the 2024 Panini NIL The Ohio State University #57 Jeremiah Smith. As the season unfolds, that card is likely to remain a focal point for buyers who want early-era cardboard tied to one of the biggest names in the sport.
For another perspective on this story, read Five College Football Players Card Collectors Should Track in 2026.
If Smith turns last year's production into an even bigger junior-season leap, his market could get hotter in a hurry. Big games, highlight catches, and Heisman-level moments would only add to the attention already surrounding him.
2. Arch Manning, QB, Texas
Few players in college football bring the same combination of name recognition, positional importance, and hobby intrigue as Arch Manning. Texas enters 2026 with major expectations, and Manning is at the center of all of it after a 2025 season in which he threw for 3,163 yards, 26 touchdowns, and seven interceptions.
Quarterbacks remain the hobby's headline position, and that reality alone makes Manning one of the most important players for collectors to watch this fall. Add in the Manning family name, the Texas spotlight, and projections that place him as a possible No. 1 pick in the 2027 NFL Draft, and it is easy to see why the market keeps such a close eye on his cards.
There is also a strong football argument behind the hobby interest. Manning appears to be set up well for a major year thanks to the structure around him. Texas has defensive support returning, including Colin Simmons after he led the SEC in sacks in 2025, and Steve Sarkisian's presence gives the Longhorns one of the more respected offensive play-callers in the game. Stable coaching, a powerful brand, and pro-level expectations are a strong recipe for collector attention.
One of Manning's notable early cards is the 2023 Panini Prizm Draft Picks Saturday Star Signatures #SSS-ARM. Early autographs often carry added appeal when tied to a quarterback with legitimate top-pick upside, and Manning's place near the top of future draft conversations gives this card a built-in audience.
For collectors, the key question is not whether Manning will draw attention. He already does. The real question is whether he can convert that attention into the kind of season that pushes demand to a higher tier. If Texas makes a serious title push and Manning posts the expected numbers, his market could become one of the biggest stories in college football cards this year.
3. Dante Moore, QB, Oregon
Dante Moore rounds out this Top 3 as another quarterback with major hobby upside heading into 2026. Oregon's signal-caller put together an impressive 2025 season, throwing for 3,565 yards and 30 touchdowns while leading the Ducks to the College Football Playoff semifinals.
That kind of production already gives Moore a strong base for collectors, but what makes him especially compelling is the overlap between team success and NFL projection. Moore is viewed as a potential top-five selection in the 2027 NFL Draft, and quarterbacks carrying that kind of outlook are always worth close attention from the hobby.
Oregon's roster strength also matters. Much of the talent from last season returns, and the Ducks are again expected to field one of the better defensive fronts in the country. That may not sound like a direct card-market factor, but it can have a major effect on a quarterback's national profile. Teams that win consistently, control games, and stay in the playoff picture keep their stars visible week after week. For collectors, visibility drives interest.
Moore's notable card to watch is the 2025 Luminance Future Signatures NIL #NIL-DME Dante Moore Autograph. If he leads Oregon on another deep postseason run, cards like that could draw more serious hobby attention, especially from buyers trying to secure an autograph before NFL Draft positioning becomes even firmer.
Among the names to monitor this season, Moore may offer one of the more interesting combinations of proven production and room for growth. He has already shown he can lead a contender. If he sharpens his numbers and keeps Oregon near the top of the national race, his cardboard could benefit from both college success and rising pro expectations.
Why these three stand out in the 2026 hobby chase
Collectors often look for a simple formula at the college level: elite production, national exposure, recognizable early cards, and a believable path to bigger moments. These three players check those boxes in different ways.
Jeremiah Smith offers game-breaking talent and major Heisman appeal as a star receiver on a marquee program.
Arch Manning brings unmatched name recognition, quarterback premium, and top-pick expectations at Texas.
Dante Moore combines proven passing production with playoff relevance and a strong NFL trajectory.
Each also enters the season with a card or autograph that collectors can track now rather than waiting for the market to move later. That early positioning is often where the biggest hobby opportunities begin.
Cards to keep on your radar
For collectors building a watch list this season, these are the three key cards tied to this Top 3 group:
2024 Panini NIL The Ohio State University #57 Jeremiah Smith
2023 Panini Prizm Draft Picks Saturday Star Signatures #SSS-ARM Arch Manning
2025 Luminance Future Signatures NIL #NIL-DME Dante Moore Autograph
None of these cards exists in a vacuum. Their appeal is tied directly to what happens on the field over the next few months. Big statistical jumps, signature wins, and national-award momentum can quickly change how collectors value college stars, especially when those players already have established hobby recognition.
What collectors should watch as the season develops
Early in the season, raw numbers matter, but context matters just as much. Collectors following Smith should watch target share, big-play consistency, and whether he becomes the centerpiece of the Heisman race. For Manning, efficiency, touchdown growth, and Texas' standing in the national title picture will likely shape the conversation. With Moore, continued production and Oregon's ability to stay in playoff position could be the biggest market drivers.
It is also worth watching how the hobby reacts to milestone moments. A monster game against a ranked opponent, a defining late-season performance, or a playoff-clinching showing can all serve as demand catalysts. College football card markets can move fast when a player is already on the national radar.
For anyone building a 2026 watch list, this Top 3 group gives collectors three different ways to follow the season: the elite playmaking receiver, the high-profile quarterback under the brightest spotlight, and the proven passer leading a perennial contender. That is more than enough reason to keep Jeremiah Smith, Arch Manning, and Dante Moore near the top of the hobby board as the season unfolds.
Photo Gallery
