Sell Your Collection

Sell your vintage sports card collection with confidence

Selling your vintage sports card collection can seem difficult, but our job is to make it easy for you.

Why Choose OTIA Sports?

Why choose OTIA Sports?

  • We pay people more for vintage (pre-1975) sports cards than any other company in the United States.
  • You will receive your cash, check or PayPal payment immediately.
  • We will buy the entire collection. No cherrypicking your best cards and leaving you with the rest to deal with.
  • We have over 20 years of experience purchasing collections, along with the best technology, people and equipment available to help us determine the value of your collection.
  • All of our offers are good for 30 days. This gives you time to shop around if you wish, and see for yourself that our offer is the highest.
How We Can Pay More

How can you pay more than any company in the country?

We have a small staff, keep our business expenses as low as possible and we are selective about the collections we purchase.

Our Simple Process

Our Simple Process

  1. Describe your collection via email, phone call or any of the social media messaging platforms. These questions are most important to answer:
    • An estimate of how many total cards are in your collection.
    • What percentage of the collection is pre-1975?
    • What, if any, complete sets do you have?
    • A list of all items in your collection is not necessary, but if you have a list please send it to us.
  2. Send us a few pictures of your collection. You can fit many cards into one picture by spreading them out. Focus on the oldest cards in your collection.

    Start with these pictures:

    • At least one picture of the entire collection so we can see the size of the collection.
    • One picture of the most valuable items in the collection, in your opinion.
    • Photos of your pre-1975 star player cards.
  3. Submit an asking price.

    We meet or exceed asking prices every day. The time and effort involved in accurately pricing a large collection can be rigorous, and asking prices allow us to make sure we are in the same general price range before we proceed.

Submission Form

Send us your collection details

You can upload multiple images and spreadsheet files. Accepted formats: JPG, PNG, WEBP, GIF, CSV, XLS, XLSX, ODS. Max 15MB per file.
Helpful Tip

A few clear photos of the oldest cards, most valuable items, and the overall collection size can help us review your submission much faster.