The market for vintage Nintendo trading cards is showing serious momentum in 2026, with multiple sales from the 1989 Topps Nintendo release posting dramatic gains. What was once a nostalgic oddball set tied to the Nintendo Entertainment System is now becoming one of the more closely watched corners of the non-sports card hobby.
Interest appears to be strongest in high-grade examples, but the price action is not limited to gem-mint stars. Even lower-priced scratch-off cards have started to move, suggesting a broader rise in collector attention for one of Topps' most distinctive late-1980s entertainment releases.
Why the 1989 Topps Nintendo Set Still Resonates
The 1989 Topps Nintendo set arrived at a time when the NES had become a defining part of pop culture. Nintendo's characters and franchises were already deeply embedded in American households, and Topps turned that popularity into a card product built around some of the era's biggest video game titles.
The release includes 93 total cards, broken into 60 scratch-off game cards and 33 sticker cards. The structure gave collectors more than standard card fronts and backs. The scratch-off format brought in a game-like element, while the sticker cards added gameplay tips and recognizable artwork tied to familiar franchises.
For more collector background, read Pokémon FireRed and LeafGreen for Nintendo Switch Now Connect to Pokémon HOME, With Celebi Reward Available.
Six games were featured across the set:
- Super Mario Bros.
- Super Mario Bros. 2
- The Legend of Zelda
- Zelda II: The Adventure of Link
- Punch-Out!!
- Double Dragon
All six games appeared in the 60-card scratch-off portion of the release. The 33-card sticker subset was narrower, focusing on Mario, Zelda, Punch-Out!!, and Double Dragon. That mix gives the product crossover appeal between trading card collectors, retro gaming fans, and character-driven nostalgia buyers.
Super Mario PSA 10 Sales Have Taken Off
One of the clearest signs of the set's changing market came from a 1989 Topps Nintendo Super Mario Bros. card graded PSA 10. Sales from early 2026 suggested a much lower baseline than what collectors are seeing now.
For another perspective on this story, read 1989 Topps Nintendo Cards See Major PSA Sale Gains.
From January 2026 through May 2026, five recorded sales averaged $183.56. Later in the year, the market changed quickly. A sale on September 11, 2026 reached $535, and another on October 2, 2026 climbed to $900.
That swing matters for more than headline value. The $535 sale represented an increase of roughly 172 percent versus that early-2026 average. The $900 result pushed the jump to about 391 percent compared with the same baseline. For a card that had already been trading regularly, that kind of move points to a significant revaluation rather than a random one-off spike.
Mario remains the centerpiece character of the set, so it makes sense that collectors would chase his cards first when demand intensifies. But the speed of the increase stands out, especially in PSA 10 condition, where supply is naturally more limited and competition tends to accelerate once a market gains attention.
The Rise Is Not Limited to Trophy-Level Cards
One of the more interesting parts of the recent movement is that the strength is not only showing up in expensive gem-mint examples. Lower-cost cards have also posted meaningful gains, including scratch-off cards that historically sat in a more affordable tier.
A PSA 9 example of card #9 from the set, the Scratch-Off Punch-Out!! card, sold for $50 on September 30, 2026. Earlier in the year, a recorded sale from May 19 came in at just $14.53.
That jump illustrates that buyers are not exclusively chasing top-pop or ultra-high-grade material. A move from the mid-teens to $50 on a PSA 9 scratch-off card suggests demand is spreading through the set. When that happens, it can indicate that more collectors are building runs, targeting favorite franchises, or entering the release at multiple price points instead of just competing for the biggest slabbed stars.
For collectors watching market behavior, that distinction matters. A hobby surge can look fragile if it only affects a handful of elite cards. A broader increase across grades and card types often suggests deeper participation.
A Mario Bros. 2 Card Reset the High End
The most eye-catching sale tied to the set belongs to a Super Mario Bros. 2 card. A PSA 10 copy of 1989 Topps Nintendo Mario Madness from Mario Bros. 2 recently sold for $7,700 on October 2, 2026 via best offer after being listed at $9,500.
Even with the accepted price coming in below the asking number, the sale still reset expectations in a major way. The previous recorded sale for that card was just $372 on May 11, 2025.
Looking at a wider history makes the result even more striking. Across the seven sales recorded between December 8, 2021 and May 11, 2025, the card averaged $314. The jump from that average to $7,700 works out to a gain of roughly 2,353.23 percent.
That kind of increase will naturally draw attention, particularly because it happened in a set that has spent years sitting outside the mainstream sports-card spotlight. It also reinforces a pattern seen in other nostalgia-driven categories: once a key card posts a truly outsized sale, the rest of the market often gets reevaluated quickly.
What Is Driving the New Attention?
Several factors may be feeding the demand behind 1989 Topps Nintendo cards.
First is pure nostalgia. The NES remains one of the most influential home consoles ever released, and franchises like Super Mario and The Legend of Zelda continue to hold cross-generational appeal. Collectors who grew up with those games are now older, more established, and more willing to spend for condition-sensitive items tied to childhood favorites.
Second is the wider expansion of the non-sports card category. Over the last several years, entertainment cards, gaming cards, and pop-culture issues have drawn stronger collector interest. That broader shift has opened the door for sets that once felt niche to find new audiences.
Third is the appeal of the product itself. This is not just a card set with licensed artwork. The scratch-off design, game-specific themes, and sticker subset with tips make it feel uniquely tied to the Nintendo experience of its era. That helps separate it from many other late-1980s non-sports products that do not have the same interactive identity.
Condition scarcity is also part of the story. Cards and stickers from novelty-oriented releases often were not handled with long-term preservation in mind. High-grade survivors can therefore become much tougher finds than casual observers might expect, especially when a fresh wave of collectors enters the market at once.
Checklist Snapshot of the 1989 Topps Nintendo Release
Collectors revisiting the set should know the basic structure before jumping into singles or unopened material.
- Year: 1989
- Manufacturer: Topps
- Total cards: 93
- Scratch-off cards: 60
- Sticker cards: 33
- Featured games: 6
Games included in the scratch-off set
- Super Mario Bros.
- Super Mario Bros. 2
- The Legend of Zelda
- Zelda II: The Adventure of Link
- Punch-Out!!
- Double Dragon
Games represented in the sticker set
- Super Mario Bros.
- The Legend of Zelda
- Punch-Out!!
- Double Dragon
The sticker cards also included gameplay tips, adding another layer of period charm that continues to appeal to collectors who remember using game guides, magazine maps, and password notes during the NES era.
What Collectors Should Watch Next
If the current pace continues, more eyes will likely turn toward unopened packs, key character cards, and top-grade examples from franchises beyond Mario. Zelda-related cards could be especially worth monitoring, given the long-term strength of that brand among game collectors. Punch-Out!! and Double Dragon may also benefit if buyers continue branching out from the most obvious flagship cards.
Another important signal will be whether mid-grade and lower-population cards keep rising alongside the marquee PSA 10 sales. If the market broadens further, the set could move from occasional nostalgia buy to established target within the vintage gaming-card space.
For now, the 1989 Topps Nintendo release has clearly moved beyond being a forgotten novelty issue. With Super Mario cards pushing sharply higher, scratch-offs gaining traction, and a Mario Bros. 2 PSA 10 reaching $7,700, collectors tracking retro gaming cardboard have a set that is generating real momentum in the current market.
Photo Gallery
