The SCN Challenge took another turn after Week 3, with the leaderboard shifting again and waiver activity becoming a bigger part of the competition. Built around a season-long mix of fantasy football logic and sports card portfolio management, the contest is starting to reveal which strategies are working early and which collections need a quick turnaround.
With several quarterback markets under pressure and a few individual cards driving major gains, Week 3 created separation at both the top and bottom of the standings. It also produced one of the more notable roster management moments of the season so far, as a waiver move had to be reversed after a valuation issue surfaced.
Trent moves back into the top spot
Trent returned to first place after Week 3 and did it without needing to make any waiver adjustments. His position at the top has been fueled by one standout performer: a 2025 Panini Prizm Tyler Shough Silver Auto graded PSA 9, which is up 60% through the first three weeks of the season.
That kind of gain is enough to move any portfolio, but it has not been a one-card story. Trent reportedly has four cards up at least 20%, with only one card sitting in negative territory. In a competition based on cumulative card-market performance, that kind of balance matters just as much as having one major riser.
For more collector background, read NFL Week 3 Card Market Watch: Raiders Surge, Fernando Mendoza Waits, and Running Backs Heat Up.
Early in the season, the challenge has already shown how important it is to stack multiple winners rather than rely on one hero card. Trent’s portfolio appears to be doing exactly that, which is why he enters the next scoring period in front.
The rest of the top three stays tight
The standings behind Trent remain competitive, even if the margin created by the Tyler Shough surge is difficult to match right now.
Second place is being held by a portfolio that has seen every card rise, but with a smaller Tyler Shough gain of 16.8%, the return has not matched the pace being set at the top. That detail underscores one of the central themes of the contest so far: ownership of the same player does not always create the same result when card selection, parallel strength, and grade all differ.
For another perspective on this story, read SCN Challenge Week 3: Trent Retakes the Lead as a Card-Value Waiver Ruling Forces a Rethink.
Jason Otero slipped from first to third after Week 3. Two cards in particular remain central to his position, a Caleb Williams Optic Red Pandora PSA 10 and a Matthew Stafford Topps Finest PSA 10 used as his hero card. With no major move from either card during the week, he gave back the lead and now enters Week 4 trying to regain momentum.
That top-three shuffle is a reminder that even small week-to-week changes can move participants several spots when the field remains close.
A waiver wire dispute becomes the biggest Week 3 story
The most debated development of the week came through the waiver process.
After Week 2, one manager moved a Caleb Williams Purple Shock PSA 10 in exchange for a 2023 Jaxson Smith-Njigba Prizm Green Scope Auto /75 PSA 9. On the surface, the swap looked straightforward. The listed Card Ladder values were close, with the Caleb Williams card at $200 and the Smith-Njigba card at $195.
Once the card was loaded into the contest collection, though, the valuation attached to the Jaxson Smith-Njigba card jumped to $685. The reason was tied to how the platform’s broader value references interacted with the card entry, creating a significant mismatch between the intended PSA 9 valuation and the number appearing in the competition portfolio.
That forced a ruling. The Smith-Njigba card had to be swapped out because the challenge valuation did not accurately reflect the PSA 9 copy that had been added. The move did not count against the season limit of five transactions, but it still altered the strategy behind the waiver decision.
Patrick Mahomes becomes the replacement play
After the reversal, the replacement target became a 2025 Topps Chrome Patrick Mahomes Blue Wave /150 graded PSA 10.
The thinking behind the move is easy to understand from a short-term market perspective. Mahomes remains one of the hobby’s most liquid and responsive stars, and schedule-based betting is clearly part of the challenge strategy. With favorable upcoming matchups against the Raiders and Chargers before a tougher stretch arrives, the hope is that a pair of strong performances could push demand higher.
There is also a recent pricing marker supporting the idea of upside. A true blue version reportedly sold for $400 near release. If Mahomes heats up over the next couple of weeks, a Blue Wave /150 could plausibly climb closer to the $300 range, which would help offset the loss of the initial waiver target.
Whether that proves to be the right call will depend on both on-field production and how aggressively collectors chase early-season 2025 Topps Chrome Mahomes color.
Why quarterback volatility is driving the contest
Quarterbacks continue to dominate the challenge, and that means the standings can swing quickly when markets cool or spike. Through three weeks, some participants have benefited from early hobby enthusiasm, while others have been hit by disappointing performances and declining card prices.
The format naturally magnifies that volatility. A single quarterback card, especially a graded parallel or autograph, can account for a large share of a portfolio’s weekly movement. If that player catches a hot streak, the card can change the standings in a hurry. If the player struggles, the drop can be just as sharp.
That dynamic has already become visible in the lower half of the leaderboard, where several managers are waiting on rebounds from key quarterback positions.
Pressure builds at the bottom entering Week 4
While the race at the top remains close, the bottom of the standings has started to develop its own storyline.
Jesse Gibson remains in last place and needs stronger hobby movement from C.J. Stroud or Jordan Love to close the gap. The standings suggest the deficit is significant enough that a routine week may not be enough. A true rebound likely needs either a major game from one of those quarterbacks or a broader market shift that lifts their cards.
Only two other participants are reportedly in negative territory alongside Jesse: Gary LeMaster and Mike Gioseffi.
Gary’s position is tied in part to the need for a Matthew Stafford rebound. Mike, meanwhile, needs Drake Maye to reverse course after a rough start in the market. Those are very different player profiles, but the challenge is the same for both portfolios: they need movement from cards that have not cooperated yet.
The biggest underperformers so far
Among the names discussed around the competition, Jordan Love and Drake Maye stand out as the two biggest disappointments to this point. Their card markets have slipped the most, reflecting the reality that collectors react quickly when expectations are not being met.
That does not mean those positions are lost. In a football-driven card contest, a strong game or two can change the tone around a player almost immediately, especially at quarterback. Still, Week 3 made it clear that holding a falling signal-caller can drag down an otherwise competitive portfolio.
For the managers tied to Love and Maye, Week 4 feels especially important. Another quiet week could make the climb much steeper. A breakout performance, on the other hand, could put them back in the mix faster than the current standings suggest.
Key cards shaping the SCN Challenge after Week 3
- 2025 Panini Prizm Tyler Shough Silver Auto PSA 9 - up 60% and leading the top portfolio
- Tyler Shough card in second-place portfolio - up 16.8%, but not enough to match the leader’s gain
- Caleb Williams Optic Red Pandora PSA 10 - still a major card in the top three, but without the move needed to hold first
- Matthew Stafford Topps Finest PSA 10 - central to one top-three portfolio and also a rebound need elsewhere in the field
- 2023 Jaxson Smith-Njigba Prizm Green Scope Auto /75 PSA 9 - involved in the week’s most controversial waiver situation
- 2025 Topps Chrome Patrick Mahomes Blue Wave /150 PSA 10 - the replacement pickup aimed at short-term upside
- Caleb Williams Purple Shock PSA 10 - the outgoing card in the disputed waiver sequence
- C.J. Stroud, Jordan Love, and Drake Maye cards - key positions for managers trying to escape the bottom of the standings
What to watch in Week 4
Week 4 will likely be defined by two questions. First, can Trent’s portfolio keep converting broad strength into separation at the top? Second, can the managers in negative territory get enough help from their quarterbacks to stop the slide?
The Mahomes Blue Wave addition is another storyline worth tracking closely. It is the kind of move that can look sharp very quickly if the player delivers and the market follows. If not, it becomes another example of how difficult it is to time short-term card swings, even with a favorable NFL schedule.
There is also the broader issue of waiver discipline. Week 3 showed that valuation mechanics matter just as much as player selection. In a contest where transaction limits and pricing benchmarks shape every decision, the technical side of card entries can be just as important as the football side.
As Week 4 begins, the SCN Challenge is no longer just about early hype. It is becoming a test of timing, risk tolerance, and how well each manager can react when the card market moves faster than expected.
Photo Gallery
