Indianapolis became the 10th NFL team to change starting quarterbacks after releasing Daniel Jones, giving Anthony Richardson another shot with the Colts. The most consequential move for football card collectors, though, could be in Las Vegas. No. 1 overall pick Fernando Mendoza is taking over for the Raiders just as 2026 Topps Chrome Football arrives.
A new starter gets more attention, but the reason he got the job matters more than the announcement. The Raiders are turning to a player they drafted to lead the franchise. Other teams are evaluating young quarterbacks ahead of a draft decision or simply trying to get through a run of injuries. Those situations can all generate interest in a player's cards, but they offer very different chances of that interest lasting.
Fernando Mendoza Gets His Shot as 2026 Topps Chrome Football Arrives
The Raiders' move to Mendoza is part of a two-team shuffle. Kirk Cousins, dealt at the trade deadline, returns to Minnesota to start for his former team. Las Vegas gets its first extended look at Mendoza. For collectors, Mendoza is the bigger story: His draft position gives the Raiders a reason to stick with him through some uneven performances, and the Topps Chrome release puts fresh cards in front of buyers just as he takes over.
The catch is the price. Multiple Mendoza card sales have already topped $10,000, a sign that some buyers are paying for the player they expect him to become. Those sales don't put every Mendoza rookie in the same price bracket, but they do make it worth asking how much of the excitement around his first start is already reflected in the card you're considering. Compare completed sales for the same card, parallel and grade rather than treating a headline sale as a benchmark for the entire market.
For more collector background, read 2026 NFL Rookie Card Report: Week 10 Rankings, QB Debuts and the Biggest Movers.
Starting immediately isn't a requirement for a top pick to build a market. Caleb Williams, Joe Burrow and Trevor Lawrence opened their rookie seasons as starters after going first overall. Josh Allen and Justin Herbert took over during their first seasons, while Patrick Mahomes and Jordan Love waited longer for full-time roles. Mendoza's eventual card market will depend much more on what he does with the job than on when he got it.
Carson Beck Is a Rookie Market to Watch in Arizona
Carson Beck got his opening with the Cardinals after Jacoby Brissett was traded to Baltimore and Gardner Minshew went to injured reserve. Beck had already given collectors something to follow in August when he went up against Carolina's Haynes King in the Hall of Fame Game. The regular-season opportunity was the next step, but Beck was injured in his first start and is set to miss the following game.
Beck is a candidate to become one of the more sought-after quarterbacks in the rookie class behind Mendoza. His situation is less settled, however. Arizona's depth chart opened because of a trade and an injury, and Beck's own injury delays the club's chance to evaluate him. Waiting for his return could give buyers a better read on whether the Cardinals see him as a long-term option.
J.J. McCarthy and Anthony Richardson Get Another Look
J.J. McCarthy's opportunity with the Giants comes with an unusual hobby angle. He and Michael Penix Jr. are the only quarterbacks from the 2024 class with true Panini rookie patch autographs, or RPAs. Collectors who specifically want that card format have a reason to follow McCarthy that goes beyond a single start.
McCarthy takes over from Jameis Winston, who stepped in after Jaxson Dart suffered a season-ending knee injury in Week 2. Unlike several teams making quarterback changes, the Giants still have a realistic path to the playoffs. That gives McCarthy a chance to play meaningful games, but a late-season run and a long-term commitment are two different things. Anyone pricing his cards as if he already has the job beyond this season is making a much bigger bet.
Richardson also has draft pedigree on his side. He was the third quarterback selected in 2023, behind Bryce Young and C.J. Stroud, and has an 8-7 record as an NFL starter. The question in Indianapolis is what his next stretch of games will show after the Colts moved much of their offensive talent at the trade deadline. Collectors watching Richardson might learn more from how he runs the offense over several starts than from the result of any one game.
What Seattle, Miami and Philadelphia Are Looking For
Drew Lock takes over a Seattle offense that has struggled to recapture its form after a Super Bowl title. He's played better than Sam Darnold this season, which gives the Seahawks a football reason to make the switch. Improving the offense down the stretch would help Lock's case, but it wouldn't necessarily settle who leads the team next season.
For Miami, starting Kyle McCord is about informing its next draft decision. The Dolphins are out of the playoff picture and expect to pick in the top three. If McCord shows he can handle the job, Miami can consider using that pick on a player such as Jeremiah Smith rather than on a quarterback. For McCord card buyers, the risk is that Miami's evaluation ends with the team drafting his replacement.
Joe Milton has a different opening in Philadelphia. With Jalen Hurts out for the year, the Eagles can give regular-season snaps to a strong-armed quarterback who previously played for New England and began the season on Dallas' practice squad. Milton can use those starts to show whether he belongs in Philadelphia's plans. Collectors should distinguish between earning a longer look and taking over the job once Hurts is healthy.
Jacoby Brissett and Tommy DeVito Fill Immediate Needs
Baltimore needed help after losing Lamar Jackson and Tyler Huntley to long-term injuries. Undrafted rookie Joe Fagnano got a chance, but the Ravens turned to the trade market after consecutive losses to Jacksonville and a Chargers team that had been 0-8. Brissett, Arizona's Week 1 starter, gives Baltimore an experienced option without changing what Jackson means to the franchise.
Tommy DeVito is back in the lineup with New England after first drawing widespread attention with the Giants. The Patriots entered the season with ambitions of another deep run after reaching the Super Bowl the previous year. DeVito's return gives collectors a familiar name to follow, but his previous NFL opportunities haven't turned into a sustained starting role. As with Brissett, there's a difference between buying a card because you enjoy the player and buying it because you expect him to keep the job.
Where to Look for Value in the Quarterback Card Market
Collectors who don't want to pay for the uncertainty around a newly promoted starter can look to established markets such as Allen, Burrow, Mahomes and Brock Purdy. First-round pedigree and continuity with the drafting team are common among top quarterback card markets, but Purdy is a reminder that draft position isn't the only route to lasting demand. For the players getting their chance now, the clearest signal will be whether their teams continue to build around them after the immediate need passes.
Injured quarterbacks are another place to look if prices soften. Jackson is the more established player, while Dart carries more uncertainty after a knee injury cut his season short in Week 2. Before buying either, compare recent completed sales with pre-injury sales for the same card and grade. That's a better test of whether you're getting a discount than assuming a player is cheaper because he's out of the lineup.